eXTReMe Tracker
1
2




melodic.net: Bon Jovi Being Sued For $400 Billion Dollars
Bon Jovi Being Sued For $400 Billion Dollars
by Tom Spinelli at 2008-10-12 Add to MySpace
Add to Facebook




Bon Jovi might be the next in line to lobby the Feds for a multi-hundred billion dollar bailout if they lose a copyright infringement case that was filed against them on Thursday. We very much doubt that Jon has a high enough credit limit on his Bon Jovi Mastercard to cover the bill he may face: $400 billion dollars. Yes, billion!

We recently told you about Boston musician Bart Steele who wrote a theme song for his home town baseball team, The Boston Red Sox, which he believed was later rewritten by Bon Jovi (see story). Steele filed a Federal lawsuit Thursday in the Massachusetts District Court's Boston Office against the veteran rockers and a host of other defendants. 

The basic claim (that we could make out) in the lawsuit revolves around a song Steele wrote in September in 2004. In the suit Steele's composition is described as a "love song for his beloved Red Sox and a baseball playoff anthem fans could sing along with. He titled his song '(Man I Really) Love this Team', also known as 'Man I Love this Team.'" Steele says that through local airplay and public performances the song became well known by fans of the team as well as members of the team and their organization. 

Steele claims that Bon Jovi recorded a promotional track for Major League Baseball called "I Love This Town" which Steele contends is a "unauthorized derivative version" of his song. Three years after Steele's song was first released to the public, the Bon Jovi track began to appear in on-air promotions for Major League Baseball and the song was also included on the rock group's 2007 CD "Lost Highway".

According the lawsuit we were forwarded by Steele, "Bart is requesting damages as authorized by the copyright law. As intent will be easy to prove, we are seeking the statutorily authorized amount of $100,000 per cd sold. Just under 4 million cds have been sold to date. This totals almost $400 billion." It further states that "Bart intends to give 99% of this recovery to musicians' rights organizations". 

The actual plot of events laid out in the lawsuit reads a bit like a John Grisham novel with Steele's David battling Bon Jovi's Goliath (a link to the lawsuit is below). And in this case Goliath isn't just the band Bon Jovi but a host of co-defendants which includes "Turner Broadcasting System, Inc., Time Warner Corporation, Jon Bongiovi, Richard Sambora, William Falcone, The American Society of Composers, Fox Television Networks, Major League Baseball, MLB Productions, A & E, A & E/AETV and AEG Live." 

We were forwarded a copy of the lawsuit which you can read here. The record of the filing can be found here. At press time we were attempting to obtain contact information for someone in Bon Jovi camp to seek a comment. If we are successful we will publish a follow-up article with their reaction. 

Note: the information and details in this article are based on the information claimed in the lawsuit. These allegations have yet to be proven in court and no admission of guilt has been made by any of the parties accused of wrong doing. 

Update: So the readers have more to judge the validity of the allegations in this lawsuit, here are some links so you can compare the two. We did include similar links in our earlier article about the allegations. The YouTube video found of the MLB promo video of Bon Jovi's "I Love This Town" can be viewed here. - Bart Steele's "Man I Really Love This Team" can be heard here. For the record the feedback we did receive from readers after we ran the original article found that most didn't really see the connection between the two beyond the overall similar theme. If it goes that far, it will be up to a jury to see if there is any real connection between the two compositions.



Website: www.bonjovi.com





Comments:

Comment from Mika at 19 Oct 2008 11:11
-This guy is a joke and his song is so completely different than Jovis just a greedy bastard trying to get some attention!!


Comment from wippsson at 14 Oct 2008 0:30
-He just want some extra promotion, but I guess it won't be in a positive way for him. He will get a lot of plays on myspace, but people will just laugh. Writing some good songs might had been smarter!


Comment from Vanessa at 14 Oct 2008 0:15
-400 Billion? He must be crazy


Comment from Ben Powell (RAINE/SO-LASUNDAY) at 13 Oct 2008 18:54
-From a musician's perspective, Steele's tune does not share the same chords, arrangement, instrumentation...NOTHING!!!! I agree with Kaj, speaking from experieince these things get VERY messy. 1 Thing is for sure, knowing the US Music law, Steele is not going to get anywhere... I fear this guy's career is now 100% over. NO companies (Publishing, Record, Management) are going to touch him... And $400Bn?!?!?!? Bill gates (Microsoft) has a personal fortune of around $60Bn... Mr Steele?!?!?! Please come back to the planet earth... ~Peace~


Comment from Tom at 13 Oct 2008 15:41
-Thank Henrick ... Updated to Billion... Sorry about that.


Comment from Henrik at 13 Oct 2008 9:03
-I was just gonna say that, there's nothing in common between the songs. So what the hell is up? $100000 per sold cd?! Come on dude, get real! Oh and the title says 400 Million Dollars..


Comment from Will at 13 Oct 2008 2:17
-Can I get this guys email so I can let him know that he's being a complete dick? Bon Jovi writes a song, some nobody hears it that wrote another song about the same thing, and claims that Bon Jovi copied it. Sounds like a grab for money to me more than anything else. This is rank with the smell of greed.


Comment from Kaj at 12 Oct 2008 18:34
-Nobody wins these cases anyway, you can write a song from A to B that is later copied note by note by another artists several years later and NADA happens, people just doesn´t care. It´s the bitter truth.


Comment from wippsson at 12 Oct 2008 17:21
-Agree, the guy must be drunk. Can't find a single tone that sounds the same. He's bitter for the money and that his song sucks big time!


Comment from Tom at 12 Oct 2008 16:54
-After listening to these two songs ... I find no similarity between the two songs other than the title and baseball referenece. They are completely different songs... Get a life dude...


 Name:
 
 Comment:
 
 
Alexisonfire´s name was from a contortionist stripper, Alexis Fire, which nearly resulted in a lawsuit from the stripper´s representatives.

 To (email):
 

 From (email):
 

 

 
The Circle
(Island Records ,2009)
 
Lost Highway
(Mercury ,2007)
 
Have a nice day
(Island Records ,2005)
 
Bounce
(Island Records ,2002)
 
SunStorm - "s/t"
(Frontiers Records ,2006)
 
Christian Tolle Project - "The Real Thing"
(independent,2005)
 
Fate - "A Matter Of Attitude"
(MTM Music ,2004)
 
Defcon - "s/t"
(Retrospect Records ,2006)
 
Fate - "s/t"
(MTM Music ,2007)





Pearl
"Little immaculate.."
(Rock)

Pragmatic
"Voice of reason"
(NuMetal)

Fen
"Trails out of glo.."
(Alternative Metal)

Kevin Gilbert
"Welcome To Joytow.."
(Progressive Rock)

New York Summer
"Ticking clocks an.."
(Modern Rock (Soft..)

Kevin Gilbert
"Bolts"
(Progressive Rock)

Kevin Gilbert
"Nuts"
(Progressive Rock)

Kevin Gilbert
"Performs Toy Mati.."
(Progressive Rock)

Avenged Sevenfold
"Nightmare"
(Alternative Metal)

Painkiller Hotel
"Afterglow"
(Alternative Rock)

Green River Ordinance
"Wait a minute mor.."
(Modern Rock)

Goo Goo Dolls
"Something For The.."
(Modern Rock)

Stilldown
"The promise and t.."
(Modern Rock (Toug..)

Hour of Shame
"Hour of Shame"
(Grunge)

Petal Shelf
"Sweet Sorrow"
(Hard Rock)

Tom Wehrle
"Mad City Tragedy"
(Pianobased Singer..)

Stan Bush
"Dream the dream"
(AOR)

Fee
"Hope rising"
(Modern Pop (Chri..)

My Dear Addiction
"New Blood"
(Metal)

Jason Masi
"Balance and Pull"
(Alternative Count..)

Southern Sons
"Nothing but the t.."
(AOR)

Goo Goo Dolls
"A Boy Named Goo"
(Modern Rock)

J Englishman
"poor li´l rocksta.."
(Modern Pop)

Getaway Car
"All Your Little P.."
(Power Pop)

Phil Roy
"Issues Options"
(Singer Songwriter..)


Epicenter VIP Ticket Giveaway
enter here»

Big Money Rustlas Flat Screen and DVD Player Giveaway
enter here»

win 30 Seconds To Mars new album
enter here»

Main Search

Search By Genre

Browse Artists

Mailing List

unsubscribe here »
» The Dirty Heads Featured In Tap Tap Revenge
» Motionless In White's Debut Album Creatures Set For Release In Europe
» My Favorite Highway Calls It Quits
» Oassis Members Form New Band Beady Eye
» New Cd Out Soon With Bleu; Pre-order To Get Non Album Tracks
» Fearless Records Announces Punk Goes Pop Volume 3 European Release Date
» New Interview Online With Anberlin
» Linkin Park To Perform At "2010 Mtv Video Music Awards"
» 10 Years Premiere "Shoot It Out" Music Video And Release Feeding The Wolves
» Godsmack's Frontman Sully Erna Full Album Preview
» Maroon 5 Talk Hands All Over
» Orianthi And Lacey From Flyleaf Debut New Single
» New Video & Free Single From J Minus
» Alter Bridge Sign With Roadrunner Worldwide For "Ablll"
» Frontiers To Release The Reunited Unruly Child´s New Album
» Joe Bonamassa Adds Dublin Concert To October Tour
» New Interview Online With Abused Romance
» 10 Years Bassist Gives Update From Road
» The Pretty Reckless Cover Eminem & Rihanna And The Xx
» Avenged Sevenfold's "Nightmare" #1 At Active Rock Radio
» American Bang Release Self-titled Debut Album
» Thrice Expect To Have New Album By 2011
» Queensryche Signs To Roadrunner/ Loud & Proud Records
» The Poodles To Release Live Cd/dvd On Frontiers
» A Day's Work Break Up
2010-09-07
Interpol
Interpol
(TBA)

Stone Sour
Audio Secrecy
(TBA)

Anberlin
Dark Is the Way Light Is A Place
(Universal Records )

Weezer
Hurley
(Epitaph Records )

The Thermals
Personal Life
(TBA)

2010-09-14
Thriving Ivory
Through Yourself And Back Again
(Wind-Up Records )

Tides Of Man
Dreamhouse
(TBA)

Brandon Flowers
Flamingo
(TBA)

Phil Collins
Going Back
(TBA)

Sully Erna
Avalon
(TBA)

more releses»